The First Solar-Terrestrial Research Campaign of
the Inter-Agency Consultative Group (IACG)
by
James L. Green, NASA
A. Nishida, ISAS
L. Zelenyi, IKI
Version 1.2
Background of IACG
The Inter-Agency Consultative Group for Space Science (IACG) was
formed in 1981 by the science administrators of four major space
agencies: the European Space Agency (ESA), Intercosmos of the
former USSR which is now the Russian Space Agency (RSA), the Institute
of Space and Astronautical Science (ISAS) of Japan, and the National
Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). The purpose of the
IACG is to increase the overall science return from their missions
through cooperation. The IACG has a World-Wide-Web site for information
about its activities and the status of the scientific campaigns
it is supporting. The IACG's first project was to coordinate the
Agency's space-based missions to the Comet Halley (Reinager, 1986)
. Several years before Comet Halley made its close encounter with
the Sun in the winter of 1985, a total of six spacecraft from
ESA, Intercosmos, and ISAS were launched to make individual observations
of the comet. Realizing that many aspects of Halley Comet science
observations be improved through cooperation, the IACG undertook
the task of coordinating all matters related to the space missions
to Halley s Comet and the observations of the comet from space.
Together, these six spacecraft were able to accomplish unprecedented
coordinated science during the comet flybys of March 6 to March
14, 1986, as a result of this cooperation. The success of the
Comet Halley activities led each agency to recognize the value
of maintaining close international collaborations. The IACG next
turned its attention to conducting coordinated Solar-Terrestrial
research.
Since its formation, the IACG has met annually wit h meetings
chaired by the recognized science head from the hosting agency.
Much of the work is carried out in three working groups and three
panels, usually in combination with another major meeting or just
prior to an IACG meeting. The three IACG working groups address
all aspects of accomplishing enhanced science coordination. Specifically,
Working Group - 1 (WG-1) is the science working group and
is chaired by Dr. Arnie Pedersen of ESA. WG-1 makes recommendations
on the potential science coordination, including:
- definition of science objectives which can only be achieved
by multiple agency missions
- identification of data requiring coordinated acquisition
- ensuring compatibility of scientific measurements
- identification and specification of appropriate solar-terrestrial
models
- formulation of data exchange policies and rules
- sponsorship of scientific workshops and symposia for the wider
scientific community
The IACG Working Group -2 is involved in supporting WG-1 through
coordinating data exchange issues between the agencies. This group
is presently chaired by Dr. James Green of NASA. WG-2 makes recommendations
on data exchange issues, such as:
- specifying the capabilities of the computer networks between
the agencies
- technical aspects of implementing information and data exchange
formats
- facilitating the science campaigns
- Working Group-3 (WG-3) is the Mission Design and Planning
Working Group and is chaired by Tono Uesugi of ISAS. This working
group supports Working Group-1 on operations aspects of the multi-mission
coordination, supported by satellite operation facilities from
each agency. Besides the working groups, three panels currently
are actively discussing future cooperative research.
- The IACG Campaigns
- To accomplish its goals of enhancing the scientific return
from its space science missions the IACG has chosen a well defined
set of coordinated campaigns, each of which have specific questions
to answer in understanding the solar-terrestrial environment that
extend well beyond the individual mission science objectives.
Presently, there has been four campaigns defined. The campaigns
are:
- 1st: Magnetotail Energy Flow and Non-linear Dynamics
- 2nd: Boundaries in Collisionless Plasmas
- 3rd: Solar Events and Their Manifestation in Interplanetary
Space and in Geospace
- 4th: Solar Sources of Heliospheric Structure Observed out
of the Ecliptic
- An Overview of the 1st Campaign
- The Airlie House Workshop on Magnetotail Energy Flow and Non-Linear
Dynamics held at Airlie House, Virginia, June 1-3, 1992, defined
two overarching science research themes, and a two-phase campaign
plan focusing on: (1) The Structure of the Global Magnetotail
System, especially during quiet periods; and (2) Magnetotail Effects
of the Global Solar Wind--Magnetosphere Interaction, especially
during active periods. The scientific objectives of the 1st Campaign
are discussed in detail in the Airlie House Workshop report edited
by Whipple and Lancaster, 1992.
The prime objective of the first campaign phase is to use the
widely-spaced IACG satellites along with ground-based data, other
spacecraft, and modeling tools to gain an understanding of the
large-scale configuration of the magnetotail system. The specific
science questions to be addressed in this campaign phase are:
- Boundary Region Structures:
- How does the thickness of the LLBL and HLBL vary with upstream
solar wind conditions (e. g., IMF orientation and strength)?
- How does the fine structure of the LLBL vary with upstream
solar wind conditions; do solar wind inhomogeneities penetrate
into the boundary layers?
- What is the evidence for reconnection along the flanks of
the magnetopause; how does the process vary as a function of upstream
conditions (IMF orientation, plasma beta, mach number)?
- Where is the magnetopause locally open and closed; how does
openness vary with upstream field orientation, distance down the
tail, and time?
- How do the large-scale vortices in the tail vary with solar-wind
speed and IMF strength and orientation; what is the evidence that
they are driven by a Kelvin-Helmholtz instability?
- Does the plasma sheet bifurcate, or form fingers, when the
IMF turns northward?
- How much of the solar wind electron heat flux enters into
the tail lobes; how is this entry regulated by the IMF?
- Quiescent Configurations
- Does the magnetosphere have a ground state during quiet conditions?
- What is the structure of the quiet-time magnetosphere?
- What are the sources of the magnetotail plasma?
- How does the high-latitude ionosphere respond to magnetospheric
activity in quiet conditions?
- How do MHD waves transfer energy under quiet conditions?
- Origin of Plasma in the Plasma Sheet
- What are the relative source strengths of the solar wind and
the ionosphere?
- What are the underlying plasma-physics mechanisms, including
convection, heating, and acceleration, that are responsible for
the transport of plasma from these source regions into the plasma
sheet?
- The second phase of this campaign deals with the storage and
release of energy within the magnetotail, especially during both
sub-storm and storm conditions, and with the many macroscale manifestations
of these energy transfer processes in the near-Earth and distant-tail
regions. The IACG suite of spacecraft is ideally suited for such
studies. The goal of the second campaign phase is to answer the
following specific set of science questions including:
- Dynamic Magnetotail Configuration
- How do the magnetotail orientation and configuration depend
on solar wind plasma properties such as the upstream density,
velocity and pressure?
- How do the magnetotail orientation and configuration, including
twisting and oblateness, depend on the interplanetary magnetic
field (IMF)?
- How does the magnetotail configuration map into the ionosphere;
in particular, how do the open tail lobes map to the polar cap
and relate to its size and location?
- Externally Driven Disturbances
- How quickly can the magnetosphere accommodate itself to new
external conditions, such as changes in the solar wind pressure,
changes in the solar wind flow direction, different polarities
of IMF, etc. (Dynamical response of the magnetospheric convection
to changes in the direction of the IMF, for example, give s us
a clue to finding where a specific mode of magnetospheric convection
is initiated and how the convective motion expands throughout
the magnetosphere).
- How is deformation of the magnetosphere induced by sudden
changes in the solar wind pressure propagated to affect the internal
state of the magnetosphere? Such changes in the internal state
may trigger instabilities that may lead to substorms.
- Does a feature in the upstream solar wind produce a coherent
response throughout the entire magnetosphere, or is there a response
only on the dayside, or in a portion of the tail, etc.?
- Internal Magnetospheric Instabilities
- What are the key processes in substorms?
- Where is the substorm trigger region?
- What disrupts magnetospheric currents during substorms, and
how are they reconfigured?
- For the 1st Campaign, the IACG core missions are Geotail
(ISAS), Wind
(NASA), Interball-Tail
(a spacecraft pair from RSA), Interball-Auroral
(a spacecraft pair also from RSA), and the Polar
(NASA) spacecraft. At this time only Geotail,
Wind,
and Interball-Tail
are in orbit. However, many of the scientific objectives defined
in the Airlie House report can now be tackled and it has been
decided to move the campaign forward. Ancillary data are also
being used in the 1st Campaign and include selected instruments
on (but are not limited to) IMP-8,
GOES
6 & 7, the Los Alamos National Laboratory equatorial spacecraft,
and a variety of ground based radar and other instruments. For
the operational core missions Table 1 lists all the instruments
and Principal Investigators for the 1st Campaign.
- Campaign Implementation
- To facilitate the execution of the first campaign, a Coordination
Committee consisting of A. Nishida (ISAS), M. Acuna (NASA), R.
Schmidt (ESA), L. Zelenyi (IKI) and the Lead Coordinator, J. L.
Green (NASA) has been formed. The responsibility of the Coordination
Committee is to represent the individual project teams within
their agency and to insure that as many of the scientific objectives
(as outlined above) as possible are addressed by the campaign.
Nearly all spacecraft and ground-base projects operate under a
set of data exchange rules that identify obligations of researchers
about data provided by other science research investigators. Because
the scientific aim of the IACG 1st Campaign is, by design, multi-mission
collaborative efforts, which greatly extends this interchange
of data within the international research community, a set of
"Rules of the Road"
have been adopted for use in the IACG 1st Campaign. The rules
provide information on how interested researchers can become campaign
members.
It has been decided that the WWW will be used to provide rapid
access to the Campaign data and information.
- Event Intervals
At the Working Group 1 meeting in Sapporo, Japan on September
6, 1995 the Campaign 1 event times were selected. These intervals
were based on having a solar wind monitor (Wind
or IMP-8)
with Geotail
and Interball-Tail
near their apogees in the mid-tail regions. The intervals are
given in the following table.
Day of the year Date
293-294 October 20 -21, 1995
299-300 October 26-27, 1995
304-305 October 31 - November 1, 1995
315-316 November 11-12, 1995
321 November 17, 1995
331-333 November 28-29, 1995
337-338 December 3-4, 1995
341 December 7, 1995
349 December 15, 1995
352-354 December 18-20, 1995
12 January 12, 1996
- The Chapman Conference on The Earth's Magnetotail: A New Perspective
is being planned for late 1996 in Japan and will be co-sponsored
by the IACG to support the presentation of the scientific results
from the analysis of the acquired data during the above campaign
intervals.
- References
Reinhart, R., The Inter-Agency Consultative Group, ESA bulletin,
1986.
Whipple, E., and H. Lancaster, editors, Toward a New Era of Global
Solar-Terrestrial Research: 1st IACG Campaign on Magnetotail Energy
Flow and Non-linear Dynamics, SAIC, October 1992.